วันอาทิตย์ที่ 1 พฤษภาคม พ.ศ. 2554

            History, the lesson through time, preaches people in present to know and understand their past of their own ancestors and ones of others for the purpose of handling the current situation that will make a contingency in future. Not studying it, things could happen twice. Learning it, bad things would occur only once while we could make good things happen twice or more although they may be different in methods, contexts, and importantly result comparing to the former. As time passes by, new factors come in, new players join in, objectives and rationales keep being changed because one thing does not last long to please the people in next generation.
            As well as art or architecture, they have definite settlement, goal, and the reason behind only in one time and that is it, staying for a while and would fade away eventually. Old masters solved and made their masterpieces which were directed to accomplish what they should be in the situation filled with various issues such as techniques, aspects, societies, politics, religions and beliefs. Great effect comes with great analysis and good homework, old masters learned history. As it is mentioned before, through the time, nothing lasts long, new players step in and learn from the old masters, dealing with situation they are facing, then finally, few of them could be new old masters to be studied again by next generation of players. Vitruvius, Le Corbusier, Venturi are respectively the mainstream or Brunelleschi looking back into the Pantheon. However, Learning from the formers does not always mean the latters must follow them. Adopting, adapting, and applying is one common solution for making good things or even better happen twice or declaring war starting a tremendous debate with strong evidence if it is seen as a bad thing.
            Pieces of work totally differ in different ages. Nonetheless, they hold one key factor. The one key factor has been through from the origin to present. It is about how architectures treat and value human and alternatively, how human treat and value architectures. Parthenon and Pantheon were built for gods, that was how human valued architectures but in order to make them value human back, Greeks created an architectural order and ratio expressing through columns; Doric, Ionic and Corinthian for the understanding of human proportion. Parthenon and Pantheon had a similar methodology which dealt and concerned with the proportion, it is how architectures valued human in return. Fast forward to Modernism, the International Style was created to serve every human without any bias to any class of society. It treated people equally as Modernists saw decoration in precedent architectures as crime and hierarchy. "Form follows function" motto shows that human must critically value architectures in term of utility. Yet, side-effect occurred as the pure white boxes ignored context and humanism because human treated the architectures only as servants, living machines made people bored in return. This led to the solid argument for Postmodernists who preferred "both…and" which could mean that architecture and human must value to each others. Expression and teasing were put in to kill Modernism arguing that they were wrong. The method of Postmodernists fought to bring up the notion that if architecture is not respected then human would not be either.
            To make a proper value and treat, history must be learned to establish argument coming with solid proof. Architects have to use history for reference as defense, simultaneously handling with contemporary issues. History and time are linear but learning and using it are circular.
            Age of Enlightenment or the Age of Reason, the period after Renaissance to Baroque and Modernism appeared as the knowledge of science and engineering become dominant, making architectural field much divided and focus on aesthetics aspect. New materials and technology proposed higher potential. People were gradually eroded by these potential, relying on reason more than religious or spiritual beliefs from precedent architectures. People started to build what seem to be sacred not for god but for themselves. Depending on science and engineering and seeing them as aesthetics are much related to the idea of Le Corbusier for seeing the construction by engineering as aesthetics although the architectures may be extravagant more than Modernism. It is the trigger of "form follows function" and the long-term effect of problem of bigness due to the notion to value architecture for technology

วันเสาร์ที่ 23 เมษายน พ.ศ. 2554

            There is something that could be comparable between the two shifts from Renaissance to Baroque and from Modernism to Postmodernism. First, Renaissance dedicated to human value as its supreme ideology rather than commonly respect to god in precedent ages and Modernism devoted to be built for everyman. But the two latters further focus on human sense and feeling, Baroque exaggerated elements, layers of decorations and drastic use of light and shadow to support human emotion while Postmodernism was made out of Modernism but with expression to public satirically. Similar part in the issue of complexity and contradiction could be found in the very blending of paintings or sculptures into architectures or the elements in architecture itself which blend more together leaving ambiguity and curiosity from part to part or wall to ceiling in Baroque architectures while Postmodernism leaves some doubt in addition and composition in what is structure and what is decoration or the comical play in serious rule set by Modernism which lead to first perception as Modernism architecture but it is investigated more, it is found out in distorted version.
            When it is about the measurement of breaking way from the firsts, Some Baroque architectures got absolutely drastic change from Renaissance ones. Postmodernism has got a good play in Modernism’s rule but it is not completely anti-rule, it is taunting rule. Most distinguished issue of breaking way in Baroque is about seem-to-be incomplete form. Distinct example is the use of oval shaped plan by both Bernini and Borromini. The method could not much reach to the leading to the question of the usual composition such as naves, aisles, or transepts, and then it is no ambiguity. All is found is chapels and niches set in circular or hexagonal way, however it amazingly allowed no impossibility to capture the whole interior with single view although inside is very composed.

วันเสาร์ที่ 2 เมษายน พ.ศ. 2554





          Masters and even old masters had different ways of interpretating and learning from origin and history. It is also because of many banal architectures at their own ages that drove them to create new style of architecture and solutions to improve and resolve problems occurring at their time.
          For the design of Santa Maria del Fiore, there was a fierce competition for persons to be chosen as a winner for the design of the dome of the cathedral. Brunelleschi was declared a winner over Ghiberti as he looked back to the dome of ancient Roman ruins, the Pantheon. At the time, the traditional buttress of Gothic style was prohibited, Italian architects regarded it as ugly makeshifts. The dome of the Pantheon is a forgotten formula of a single shell of concrete, Brunelleschi followed the formula but applied the dome with double shell made of sandstone and marble. He solved the spreading problem by making base of dome to be octagonal rather than round. This would let all pressure going down to the eight corners of the dome.
         When it comes to the time during and after World Wars, gigantic quantity of economical residence are needed. Le Corbusier's architectures quite followed the declaration in Vitruvius' "De architectura" that a good building must have firmitus(firmness), utilitus(commodity) and venustus(delight). although he may not be concerned much with the third one, he was driven to create five points of architecture. In order to make a form of a building, he attempted to have the shape of the building simple and basic and be relevant much to human. It should derive from nature but nature there is nothing simple and geometric. However, what he found in every matter of nature is golden ratio appearing in long history.
         Further to modernism, plenty of boredom in box and box building has appeared. The irony postmodernism emerges after the serious and formal modernism. For Vanna Venturi house which is designed by Robert Venturi, Venturi taunted and pointed out the boring formality of modernism ironically. Asymmetric facade which seems to be symmetric, The arch on front facade deceiving to be structure but actually a decoration, gable roof pretending to be flat roof are the elements for teasing predecessor. In addition, the house has some reference to the historic architecture, the front facade tried to refer to Michaelangelo's Porta Pia. It may be what Venturi suggests that some traditional method and decoration which is a taboo for modernists should be utilized again for creating symbol and making appropriate ambiguities.

วันเสาร์ที่ 26 มีนาคม พ.ศ. 2554

Before the contradiction between modernism and postmodernism appears, There was some similar attempt to stay away from boredom which is compatible with Venturi's preference of grey color. There was idea of Vladimir Tatlin's the monument to the third international. Its role is to be the headquarter of international communism. The work is inspired by constructivism art which takes viewer away from traditional art. It is influenced by the use of industrial material such as glass and metal sheet creating geometry as and admiration for machine and technology at that time, and rejecting the idea of abstract art and seeking to link itself to tangible idea. The monument to the third international or in short, "Tatlin's tower" has an amazing form expressing for people. It may be quite strange that its shape may not be resembled to the painting of constructivism art like Malevich's but it still got influenced from the art. Although, it was never actually built due to requirement of high amount of metal and context of housing shortage, Tatlin attempted much to draw the idea from constructivism into architecture. If constructivism art is parallel to de stilj or mimimalism movement, then the international style could be more fabulous, getting rid of boredom like postmodernism.
          Postmodernsim, the retaliation from boredom emerges to regard Modernism as dystopia. The well-known functional form and space, straight-forward methods of modernist architectures is counteracted by aesthetics and visible ideas of postmodernsim architectures. It has returned with ornament and unnecessary things concerned with human sense and thought which are taboos for modernism. The words form modernist architects regard postmodernsim as common, ordinary and filled with populist value. On the other hand, postmodernists reply to the buildings by modernists as too simple, abstract, and soulless. Modernists seeks to acquire purity and clarity in form and material like a white color. The reason Robert Venturi prefers grey because he wants architectures to be embrace more cultural vision and expression. The living-machine idea of Le Corbusier may be right and perfect but people are not machine, they are human, they do still have sense and emotion. Philip Johnson initially starts his work with the international style,yet eventually he could not stand any more of rows and box of glass reflecting to see each other's box of glass again and again. Architectures need to be more expressive. So, his later works got influenced by purity and abstraction of minimalism movement and populist expression of Pop Art in balance.

วันอาทิตย์ที่ 20 มีนาคม พ.ศ. 2554

          Bigness of building or architecture in modernism, has appeared in about the past 30 years. Modern and contemporary ages have proposed new technologies boasting about breaking-through the limit which exists at their ages. Nowadays, bigness seems to be distant away from architectural territory. Bigness has currently been independent and yielded much to technologies and construction method by engineers and contractors or mind-driving force by politicians. When it has to be really dealt with architects, the dis honesty between exterior and interior could occur. The facade and the inside could absolutely be incompatible to each other like two separated projects. The goal of bigness only aims to show power and greatness, boasting the potential to reach or break through the maximum as much as it could.
          However, there is an advantage of bigness, bigness could still be possible to be arranged properly since it proposed the a combination in space and function, organization of dependence and independence rather than one isolated element. There should be always reminding why the issue has to be added. Bigness has not actually appeared in past 30 years but in precedence, some wonder such as the great wall of China, it had a strategic reason to construct for preventing the outside barbarians at that time. But currently, its bigness is in major left to be comprehended for power and greatness so amazingly that a satellite could easily spot the wall, not like Eiffel tower, that Frenches have become sick seeing it everyday, everywhere as long as they are still in its viewing territory.

วันอาทิตย์ที่ 6 มีนาคม พ.ศ. 2554

"Less is more", the magnificent quote by Mies van der Rohe indicates that any problem in architectures could not be solved permanently. There is no ending of solution in any problem in architecture, it could be kept continuing. When Mies is solving on it, he breakthroughs by ignoring some aspect of the building. If he is not selective in the problem, then more problem he would have to solve and the building would not be potent and distant from the point it should be. Rationalization and simplification are the tools. However, simplification must not be over-simplification. Over-simplification could make an unexpected simpleness occurs which is too straight-forward. This kind of simpleness makes a bland architecture, then "less is a bore."




Farnsworth house is considered Mies's greatest work. The house is composed of Mies' vision of modern architecture for the technology in that time. A single space in a minimal "skin and bones" framework. The house is clearly understandable for the arrangement of architectural parts. The idea is expressed with clarity and simplicity by using materials honestly. The method allows to express their own individual character. When it comes to Glass house by Philip Johnson, he found the Farnsworth house as an inspiration to make his own version. but the house becomes too diagramatic as it is too simplified in arrangement.



วันเสาร์ที่ 26 กุมภาพันธ์ พ.ศ. 2554

Louis I. Kahn is an American architect who infuses international style with his work but also maintains his preference from the inspiration by many ancient architectures during his travelling. Kahn is famous for making monumental architecture which is compatible to human scale and he is also distinct for the arrangement of served and service space.


Some building he left to, Salk institute for biological studies, The founder, Dr. Johan Salk asked Kahn to make a building worth as if Picasso could come to pay a visit. Since it is at coastal area, Kahn integrated large outdoor space into the middle of the building which cause a sense of welcome into the institute by the background of nearby sea. It is also helping scientists to clear up their mind after long serious work by the view of the blue sea.


While he travelled to see many ancient architectures, he is impressed by the columns used at the time for the duty as a giver of light, it is a play between aperture which allows light in and the building itself which allows shadow. The materialization and the method he performed for the institute emphasize the honesty of material which is one of the principles of modernism by heavily expressive and bare concrete.

วันอาทิตย์ที่ 6 กุมภาพันธ์ พ.ศ. 2554

Well, Wolfe mentioned much about Le Corbusier, Gropius, Mies van der Rohe through the writing with the significant movement of architecture in Europe. What about America?, of course, there is Frank Llyod Wright and he has no dealing with so-called international style from Europe. Wolfe seems to put much Wright's dislike toward the important three above which I think it is not a setup. The great architecture done by Wright Wolfe put in the writing as an example, Robie house, has nothing to do with the movement of international style but holds the Prairie style. Prairie style echoes the wide, flat, tree-less expanse of the mid-western America. It is included in the philosophy of organic architecture which is concerned with human habitation and nature. The philosophy suggests that architecture should look as it naturally grew form the site, integrated but not vernacular. Compared to the along-side international style, it caused a prominent contrast, as one is nature-based but the other is machine-based.

วันอาทิตย์ที่ 30 มกราคม พ.ศ. 2554

 If we don't consider much about Wolfe's thought but his description on modernism architectures. There is one thing that they really succeed, the distinction of architecture and building is much set up seriously. International style provides much more high order. The masters like Gropius, Le Corbusier, Mies van der Rohe guided the way of modernism. But this happens in only Europe at the time, then what is going on in America, the architects could just listen to what clients ask, giving no arguments. Being American architect only spread out what clients are pleased with through the skyscrapers containing amazingness by its reaching to the sky which Wolfe could call them Christmas tree. Europeans could just walk away from this. So much did the Vienna Secession, that is why it is founded. Karl Marx's manifesto spread out the idea much about capitalism. It must be eradicated, bourgeois could control almost everything by financial power. Architect's own idea will be kept letting no go of their arguments. The only thing that clients only matter must be only funding, not everything they ask to put in into the building.

วันเสาร์ที่ 22 มกราคม พ.ศ. 2554

O beautiful, for spacious skies, for amber waves of grain, has there ever been another place on earth where so many people of wealth and power have paid for and put up with so much architecture they detested as within thy blessed borders today?

Tom Wolfe, an another person who does not prefer much about modern architectures. It seems that moderism in care about the soul of the buildings but not the one of human. The Bauhaus has brought in the “International style” to the buildings. So has Le Corbusier’s so-called words “Machines for living”. They insist that the honesty must be brought in into the feature of each materials of the buildings. Moreover, Albers when he was teaching at Bauhaus school would ignore the small paper works made into Gothic castles, airplanes, birds, etc. but would pick up the student’s absentminded paper work which was made into a simply-folded tent and say “this makes use of the soul of paper.” The modern soul of the building must be expressed on the buildings without any fancy decoration. It is true that simplification is a great dealing in order to get efficiency. But what about the souls of people, the souls of society which lives in a context of a lot of glass boxes whose glass would in turn reflect the glass boxes next door and keep going like this. Modern souls wins but the spirit of human has gone unnatural and would fade away.